Pristine Classical e-Newsletter - Click here to subscribe

Pristine News: Friday 12th February, 2010



Pristine Audio SI logo
Introducing Pristine Audio SI

In this week's newsletter:

  • New this week - Beethoven's 5th Symphony & 5th Piano Concerto: Scherchen & Badura-Skoda
  • New This Week - The Magic Key of RCA: Stokowski, Ormandy, O'Connell, Iturbi, Marian Anderson...
  • PADA Exclusives - Spanish composer Gustavo Pittaluga conducts his own ballet suite in 1930
  • Reviews - Latest reviews, e-mails and comments



Editorial - Introducing Pristine Audio "SI"

A few weeks ago I wrote about the question of what should be kept and what should be removed when restoring old recordings, and received a number of fascinating responses. I'd like to pick up on the idea and take it a little further, based both on this week's and last week's new releases.

Last week we issued a collection of recordings made in 1943 by Sir Thomas Beecham with the Seattle Symphony. In the middle of one of the Wagner pieces the original acetate disc from which the recordings were drawn had skipped at the time of transfer. It has since been destroyed, so this is all we've got. Not a problem when the stylus skipped backwards and repeated a short section or phrase - this was easily edited out - but when it skipped forwards I was left with a 3-second gap of music which, quite simply, didn't exist.

My solution was to artificially "age" a newer recording, digitally slow it down to match Beecham's tempo, crossfade in and out of it at the appropriate point having matched the levels, and then copy in some of the background hiss from the Beecham original to mask the much quieter background of the 'patch'. The music flowed convincingly and - even if you know exactly where the patch starts and finishes - it's just about totally impossible to detect.

Is this a legitimate use of the restorer's tools? Is it any better or worse than someone repairing a ripped old master painting and having to resort to brush and oils to repair the damage? If the finished article appears as it would have done prior to the damage being done, does it matter? It's a question which brings out some quite strong opinions, and I personally think the answer lies in the grey area between a firm yes or no, and depends entirely on the material in question and the nature of the missing bars.

This week I came upon a different dilemma with the Badura-Skoda/Scherchen Beethoven Piano Concerto No. 5. My first copy was apparently near-mint, and certainly on a visual inspection looked fine. But repeated peak distortion suggested either a fault with the pressing or some unusual wear damage in the past. Given that it was indeed a very early pressing I decided to try tracking down a later pressing, which when it finally arrived improved things tremendously.

However, there was considerable disparity between the two sides with regard to background noise - side two, including the quiet middle movement, was significantly noisier than side one. Not such a problem when you have to break to turn over the record, but when the recording becomes continuous it's suddenly a rather uncomfortable sonic jump - it jars and ruins the illusion of continuity in the piece. Furthermore the sound quality itself wasn't all that a 1950s recording can be - it all seemed a little blurred and ever so slightly dulled.

The fact that this followed a slightly more recent but far better recording all round - the Symphony No. 5 - only added to my problems. I wanted the concerto to at least approach in quality the sound of the symphony. I obviously didn't want to downgrade the latter to match the former, but all attempts to really clean up the concerto as much as I'd have liked resulted in an unwarranted further deadening of the sound, especially in that troublesome second movement. Make it too bright and the hiss took over.

In the end, the concerto recording had been fully restored some three times before I was satisfied that I'd done all I could. There really are only so many times you can keep working away on specific faults in a recording - sometimes starting again from scratch is the best answer, learning from everything you've already taken from the earlier attempts. Time consuming enough when the recording runs to 30 or 40 minutes, but something I'd rather avoid with complete Wagner operas! It's a very tricky question when you're mired in the middle of a difficult restoration: should I carry on from where I am, or should I start over? There's no knowing whether a new beginning will yield any better results than you've already achieved - sometimes you simply have to know when to stop and admit it's as good as it's ever going to get...

Which brings me to our other new release this week - The Magic Key of RCA. As soon as I read the performers and track listing for this 1937 radio programme I knew I'd want to hear it, and so would others. But what about the sound quality? For weeks it's been sitting in a dusty corner of my hard drive, quietly
winking at me, as if asking if and when I might finally put it out, but then reminding me why it's remained unissued when I once again tackle its at-times drastic sonic shortcomings.

In short: I didn't want it issued in such a way as to potentially damage the reputation of our catalogue. The idea of a newcomer to Pristine, be it a customer or an influential reviewer, coming across this as the first evidence their ears get to hear of a Pristine XR release, and concluding that this was par for the course, was not one I really wanted to contemplate.

But as a handful of other 'difficult' but intriguing recordings started to add to a mounting list of apparently unreleaseable recordings - and with the knowledge that this would certainly not deter a lot of enthusiasts - I came up with the idea of an alternative 'imprint' (for want of a better word) which would clearly indicate diminished quality of an otherwise important recording. We've had XR, and now we also have SI, or 'Special Interest'.

The idea is that Pristine SI releases will complement our general catalogue, but will be well-flagged for reduced sound quality (and a description provided). Frankly I could probably have used this on one or two of our previous releases as well! Nevertheless, it should help unlock a few otherwise unheard recordings, and whilst each will benefit from a full XR remastering restoration, I won't be tempted into working away at them over and over again trying in vain to turn them into something they never can be.

And in an attempt to pre-empt the obvious question "if the quality's not so good why do they all cost the same?" - the answer is simple: they take just as long to restore and remaster, if not longer, as the recordings which sound great - the effort that goes into them is the same, even if the end result falls short of our usual standards as a result of the source material's quality.

Whatever the source, the end quality of SI recordings will be as good as we can possibly make it!


Andrew Rose, St. Méard de Gurçon, France

P.S. Thank you for all the best wishes regarding my health after last week's abridged e-mail - fortunately it was one of those short-lived viruses which left me pretty incapable for a couple of days but which quickly passed out of my system.









New release today:

Beethoven's Fifths
Pristine Audio PASC 213

Royal Philharmonic Orchestra
conductor Hermann Scherchen

Paul Badura-Skoda, piano
Vienna State Opera Orchestra
conductor Hermann Scherchen
Recorded 1954 & 1951

Transfers and XR remastering by Andrew Rose, January & February 2010 
Cover artwork based on a photograph of Hermann Scherchen

Total duration: 70:37 
©2010 Pristine Audio.

For more download and CD options, see our website

The FLAC downloads:

Ambient Stereo FLAC

16-bit Mono FLAC
24-bit FLAC


Scherchen's excellent Beethoven series continues

Two splendid 'fifths' performances in superb XR-remastered sound

 

  1. BEETHOVEN Symphony No. 5 in C minor, Op. 67 [notes / score]

    Played by The Royal Philharmonic Orchestra*
    conductor Hermann Scherchen


  2. BEETHOVEN Piano Concerto No. 5 'Emperor' in E flat, Op. 73 [notes / score]

Soloist Paul Badura-Skoda, piano
Played by Vienna State Opera Orchestra 
conductor Hermann Scherchen

1: Studio recording, Walthamstow Assembly Rooms, London, September 1954
2: Studio recording, Vienna, June 1951

*Recording under the pseudonym "Philharmonic Symphony Orchestra of London"


Beethoven's Fifths - his Symphony No. 5 and Piano Concerto No. 5, are two of the greatest works either form has ever produced. Both have seen innumerable performances and recordings since their composition during the composer's incredibly fertile middle period between 1804 and 1810.

Here we bring you newly XR remastered studio recordings from the baton of the great Hermann Scherchen, who set these down on tape for LP issue by Westminster Records in the first half of the 1950s.

The earlier recording, the Emperor Concerto was made in Vienna in 1951 with Paul Badura-Skoda at the keyboard, and was considered one of the finest of its era. The 5th Symphony was brilliantly captured by the Westminster engineers in London in 1954.

Both are superb additions to our Scherchen Beethoven series.


Download listening sample: Sample MP3 (5th Symphony, 1st mvt., Ambient Stereo)


Notes on the recordings:

These two recordings indicate quite powerfully the swift advances in sound quality which were obtained in orchestral recordings through the 1950s. Despite there being just three years between them, the 1951 recording of the Piano Concerto No. 5 can sound at times like it belongs to a different era when the two are compared directly.

There could be a number of reasons for this - tape technology was still in its commercial infancy, and the degree of hiss to be heard on the earlier recording is substantially higher than that of the Symphony No. 5 recording. But there is more to it than this - there is an added directness and clarity about the Symphony recording which the Concerto quite simply lacks.

The reasons for this are not too difficult to guess, and one immediately suspects both the choice and placing of the microphone(s) used to make each recording. Whilst the recording techniques used for the 1951 recording would have seemed perfectly adequate for the 78rpm era (which was still in full swing - though not for much longer), they had simply yet to address fully the technical and sonic advances offered by the new vinyl LP disc.

In short it's reasonably good for 1951, but would not have been considered good for 1954. My aim has been to ameliorate the shortcomings of the original as much as possible and to keep the overall sound as open as I could - as a result there are slightly higher levels of background tape hiss still to be heard on the Concerto recording.

This is my third restoration of my second transfer of this concerto recording - and in it I believe I was finally able to do justice to both the performance and the recording.

Meanwhile the Symphony was, comparatively speaking, a breeze - one of those wonderful recordings which almost fell off the record thanks to a combination of excellent original coupled with a superb pressing, all of which improved further with XR remastering to bring out the very best in it - a restorer's delight!

Andrew Rose



 

Available as 320kbps MP3, 16-bit mono or Ambient Stereo  FLAC, 24-bit FLAC, CD
or listen on demand with Pristine Audio Direct Access
(PADA)







New release today:

The Magic Key of RCA: April 18, 1937
Pristine Audio PASC 214

Marian Anderson - contralto 
José Iturbi - conductor, solo piano 
The Philadelphia Orchestra
Charles O'Connell - conductor, arranger 
Eugene Ormandy - conductor 
Leopold Stokowski - conductor, arranger 
Recorded 1937

XR remastering by Andrew Rose at Pristine Audio, February 2010
Cover artwork based on photographs of Ormandy, Stokowski, Iturbi & Andersom

Total duration: 59:36 
©2010 Pristine Audio.

For more download and CD options, see our website

The FLAC downloads:

Ambient Stereo FLAC

16-bit Mono FLAC



A stellar line-up for a truly "Magic" hour of radio

Launching the Pristine Audio "SI" - Special Interest - historic series

 

  1. Introduction (Milton Cross)
  2. BACH (arr. Cailliet) Prelude & Fugue in F minor (cond. Ormandy)
  3. DEBUSSY Nocturnes - Fêtes (cond. Iturbi)
  4. Ben Grauer speaks for RCA Victor
  5. BIZET Carmen - Prelude (cond. O'Connell)
  6. FRANCK (arr. O'Connell) Grand Pièce Symphonique - Andante (cond. O'Connell)
  7. Ben Grauer on the Orchestra's tour
  8. Stokowski on sound reproduction and Bach and Debussy
  9. BACH (arr. Stokowski) My Jesus in Gethsemane (cond. Stokowski)
  10. DEBUSSY (arr. Stokowski) Clair de Lune (cond. Stokowski)
  11. VERDI Don Carlos - O don fatale (Marian Anderson, cond. Ormandy)
  12. CHOPIN Waltz No. 2 in A flat, Op. 34, No. 1 (Iturbi)
  13. WAGNER Die Walküre - Ride of the Valkyries (cond. Ormandy)
  14. Ben Grauer on the tour and Victor
  15. Closing - Cross and Grauer over BACH Suite No 3 - Aria


The Philadelphia Orchestra

Marian Anderson - contralto
José Iturbi - conductor, solo piano
Charles O'Connell - conductor, arranger
Eugene Ormandy - conductor
Leopold Stokowski - conductor, arranger

Programme introduced by Milton Cross and Ben Grauer

Broadcast from The Philadelphia Academy of Music, 2-3pm EST, Sunday 18th April, 1937, on NBC Blue Network

 


What a line-up! One hour of live radio brings forth the Philadelphia Orchestra under four conductors: Stokowski, Ormandy, Iturbi and Charles O'Connell.

There's a piano solo from the great Iturbi, and to cap it all, a superb rendition of Verdi's O don fatale from legendary contralto, Marian Anderson - together it's a truly magnificent recording.

The catch? Well the sound quality is really not that great. We've been holding this back for a while now, wondering how best to present it. It's been XR remastered - which made massive improvements to the audio - but like too many recordings we have not released yet, it will always be compromised (unless a better source turns up).

We do suspect that a lot of people would really love to hear these performances, so today it launches our new Special Interest label.


Download listening sample: Sample MP3 (O don fatale, Ambient Stereo)


Notes on the recordings:

The Magic Key of RCA ran as an hour-long musical variety programme on an almost-weekly basis for 204 episodes over four years, between 29th September 1935 and 18th September 1939. The broadcasts went out on Sunday afternoons between 2pm and 3pm on NBC's Blue network, and featured a very wide range of artists and guests - the very first broadcast, for example, included contributions not only from conductor Walter Damrosch and singer Paul Whiteman, but also Walt Disney and radio comedians Amos 'n' Andy.

The 79th broadcast of 18th April 1937 came live from the Philadelphia Academy of Music, on the eve of the Philadelphia Orchestra's five-week "coast-to-coast tour of 11,000 miles with stops at twenty-four cities" under Ormandy and Iturbi, travelling on a "special de-luxe 9-car Pullman train". The broadcast carefully promotes not only the tour, but also RCA Victor's long association with the orchestra, and of course RCA's own electrical products.

In fact the "Magic Key" series came about as a means of promoting an electronic tuning aid developed by RCA for its radios in 1935, and was one of a number of 'magic' references dreamed up by RCA's PR department, as this excerpt from a technical website makes clear:

RCA registered their first electron-ray tube, the 6E5, on June 27, 1935. This tube initially appeared in RCA’s console-model product line that same year. RCA was fearing a loss of market share to competitors’ new lines of very small and midget radios, many of which were designed and produced in Los Angeles. RCA’s promotion touted the "Magic Eye" as an elegant feature of their upper product line - where profit margins were greatest. Not surprisingly, the 6E5 wouldn’t fit inside the competitors’ smallest sets. The name "Magic Eye" quickly gained acceptance with the public as the standard identity for the electron ray tube and tuning eye feature in consumer radio sets, regardless of manufacturer.

RCA’s marketing department went on a bit of a binge with the "Magic" theme as it popped up in a variety of other radio features. This included the "Magic Brain" tuning unit, the "Magic Voice" sound system, the "Magic Wave" antenna, and the "Magic Key" station programming system. Two of RCA’s 1936 model year console sets introduced in late 1935, Models 9K and 13K, were really "Magic". Along with the "Magic Eye", they were equipped with a combination of the other "Magic" features. The public however was not as impressed with these other "Magic" promotions as none of them gained the lasting familiarity of the "Magic Eye."

(from http://home.pacbell.net/philbert/tuning_eye/eyeintro.htm)

 

 

A Pristine Audio SI Release: Important Technical Note

Pristine SIThe source recording for this release, supplied to me by Edward Johnson of the Stokowski Society, appeared to have originated from an AM broadcast recording captured on acetate discs.

However, it had already received some quite strong noise processing which I was unable to undo, hence the release's designation as an "SI" release, meaning of "Special Interest" - but of reduced fidelity.

It has been fully restored and XR-remastered, greatly improving the sound quality over the original as supplied, but several aspects of the audio had already been compromised beyond restoration. We believe that, for many collectors, this will prove secondary to simply having this remarkable recording available to listen to.

Pristine Audio SI releases, although processed at 32-bit or higher resolution, are not available as 24-bit downloads as there is no sonic improvement possible over the standard 16-bit versions of these issues.

Andrew Rose



 

Available as 320kbps MP3, 16-bit mono or Ambient Stereo  FLAC, CD
or listen on demand with Pristine Audio Direct Access
(PADA)





New MP3 transfers at PADA Exclusives
by Dr. John Duffy
in Ambient Stereo

Pittaluga
conducts Pittaluga

The Group of Madrid
Spring 1930, the "Group of Madrid". From left to right: Julián Bautista, Rodolfo Halffter, Gustavo Pittaluga, Fernando Rivet and Salvador Bacarisse.

Pittaluga
Ballet Suite:
"Romeria de las Cornudos" 

M. T. Estremera (sop.)
Symphony Orchestra 
cond. Pittaluga 
Rec. 1930 

Gustavo Pittaluga (1906-1975) was one of the 'Group of Madrid' which formed in 1930. Pittaluga, decribed as "perhaps the most iconoclastic composer of this generation", conducts here his very Spanish-tinged ballet suite.

Further notes

At the beginning of the 20th century, there were three currents that set the pace of music: Neoclassicism, Serialism and Nationalism. Within the neoclassicists we can differentiate between two different trends: The first one, which was led by Stravinsky, had a cosmopolitan character and the second one, which took hold in Spain, became a nationalist movement.

What started as impressionism with Turina and the early Manuel de Falla, later evolved into nationalism. The inspiring works were composed during the 1920’s: El Retablo de Maese Pedro and the Concierto para Clavecín. These works influenced a group of composers living in Madrid who became the musical branch of the Generation of 1927.

El Grupo de Madrid, 1930

These composers, known as “El Grupo de los Ocho” or “El Grupo de Madrid,” became associated with the literary movement through the figure of the great critic Adolfo Salazar (1890-1958).

These eight composers —Rodolfo and Ernesto Halffter, Rosa García Ascot, Juan José Mantecón, Salvador Bacarisse, Julián Bautista, Gustavo Pittaluga and Fernando Remacha— began to meet with one another in 1930. Adolfo Salazar was the musical soul of what was known as the Residencia de Estudiantes.

This “student residency,” born from the Institución de Libre Enseñanza, was founded in 1876 and inspired by the ideas of German pedagogues Krause and Frobel. It offered an alternative to the old education controlled by the state and was a decisive factor in the evolution and interaction of poets, visual artists and musicians.

Lorca, Alberti, Buñuel and Dalí had a very close contact with other artists, intellectuals and with eminent international figures that were frequently invited: Einstein, Bergson, Freud, Paul Valéry, and so forth.

Adolfo Salazar’s influence on “El Grupo de los Ocho” was really great. Defending his musical and aesthetic values in his position as critic for the Madrid newspaper, “El Sol” (“The Sun”), he stimulated in these young composers the desire for the renovation of Spanish music.

Salazar advocated for an evolution beyond Manuel de Falla, seeking aesthetic support in the new European avant-garde: Debussy, Stravinsky, Ravel, Bartók and even Schoenberg.

These creators from “El Grupo de los Ocho” contributed with different alternatives to those proposed by Salazar, among them that of a stylized regionalism.

There was another group that originated in Barcelona, whose philosophy also differed from Salazar’s: The C.I.C. (Catalonian Independent Composers)—Manuel Blancafort, Joan Gilbert Camins, Roberto Gerhard, Agusti Grau, Ricardo Lamote de Grignon, Federico Mompou, Baltasar Samper and Eduardo Toldra—. Although some of its members, like Mompou and Gerhard, achieved international recognition, this group had a very short life.

Among many other composers who lived during these times and who were isolated from the rest was Antonio José Martínez Palacios, perhaps the most talented of all.

Fates

It is not easy to evaluate whether “El Grupo de Madrid” reached its goals. The Spanish Civil War disbanded this and other intellectual groups after 1936. Besides Ernesto Halffter, who lived in Lisbon during the war and later returned to Spain, all of them, except Remacha, left the country.

For some others there was no way out: on October 11, 1936, Antonio José Martínez Palacios was executed at Monte Estepar, near Burgos, his city of birth.

His death, a close resemblance to the death of García Lorca, symbolizes the loss of this generation of creative geniuses, whose innovations never did make a full impact. However, it was because of exile that these composers influenced beyond the Spanish frontiers, mainly in South America: Rodolfo Halffter in Mexico, Ernesto Halffter in Portugal and Julián Bautista in Argentina, to mention only a few.

In Spain, under Franco, the names of these artists almost disappeared and the influence was very small. It was towards the end of this dark age when some historians like Antón García Abril, Cristóbal Halffter, Ramón Barce and Tomás Marco began to investigate, uncovering real treasures.

Even Ernesto Halffter had certain influence during the last years of Franco’s régime: In 1960, he finished the last opera of Manuel de Falla, La Atlántida. a work that otherwise would have become unpublished.

 

This transfer is presented with Ambient Stereo remastering by Dr. John Duffy.

Over 400 PADA Exclusives recordings are available for high-quality streamed listening and free 224kbps MP3 download to all subscribers.

Remastered by 
Dr John Duffy
In Ambient Stereo




Download or stream this recording and many others from only One Euro a week!

Hundreds of historic recordings are available for listening and free MP3 download
  to subscribers to PADA Exclusives, our €1/week streamed audio service.


Other subscription offers give you full access to our entire online catalogue





Latest Reviews, e-mails & comments

"Conductor Felix Weingartner (1863-1942) belonged to a literalist tradition in German music-making not far removed from the style of Arturo Toscanini, as both eschewed the more excessive aspects of Romantic exaggeration and musical histrionics. Weingartner made his mark on the history of recordings with a first complete cycle of Beethoven symphonies. His penchant for orchestration embraced Beethoven’s Hammerklavier Sonata and Bizet’s Variations chromatiques. Producer and engineer Mark Obert-Thorn has expertly resuscitated some of the rarer materials Weingartner bequeathed us from Basle, including the 1928 realization of his own incidental music excerpt for The Tempest, previously issued only in Switzerland. Only the 1928 Invitation to the Dance--from the same May 3 session--appeared in the USA.

The program opens with the Der Freischuetz Overture (3 May 1928) in relatively thin sound and distant acoustics, so the otherwise distinctive horn and woodwind scoring of the piece is lost, more the wont of pre-electrical recording techniques than the recording date would indicate. Typical of any Weingartner performance, we do enjoy a strong architectural sense, the musical periods shaped along natural breathe periods. The Schubert B-flat Entr’acte from Rosamunde (3 May 1928) proves more successful, the lyricism in the forward strings retained along with resonant woodwinds. Tempos are generally brisk, andantino, the lines long and elastic. Weingartner’s own music for The Tempest (3 May 1928) projects a fairy-land ethos, the harmonic syntax closer to Shreker than to Mendelssohn, the bass harmonies complementing the upper register in flute and pizzicato strings. The middle section exploits a nasal falsetto sound in thin violins, with warbles and plucked notes beneath. As for Weingartner’s orchestration of the Weber Invitation to the Dance (3 May 1928), it certainly is not Berlioz. While Weingartner assigns some of the same tissue to cellos and violins, he does not mind adjusting the extended line among several choirs, including harp and bass fiddles. Weingartner’s innate love for counterpoint manifests itself, and some of the stretti become simultaneously ponderous and hectic.

The recording of Mendelssohn’s 1842 Scottish Symphony (27 March 1929) with the Royal Philharmonic sets a lovely standard of execution, linear, sympathetic, vocally shaped.  Sonic definition in the clarinets, strings--especially the violas--and tympani remains strong. Weingartner brings out the seamless mastery of the Mendelssohn mature style, beautifully integrating the two main themes of the first movement. The pentatonic Vivace--in sonata-allegro form rather than a true scherzo--basks in a kind of bright and sportive Caledonian flavor. The RPO woodwinds, horns and whirling strings are in martial spirited form. The Andante possesses something of Schumann’s romanticism, although the scoring is more delicate. Weingartner milks the string line, with its plucked harp-like accompaniment, with tender affection. The march of the secondary theme casts a somber and devotional hue on the work. Much of the vigorous, even fierce Finale resounds with fugal techniques we hear in the Fingal’s Cave Overture. Weingartner takes the move to 6/8 and A Major with aggressive authority, allowing this “warlike” piece to conclude with a brilliant authority, a performance that certainly stands the test of time."

-- Gary Lemco, Audiophile Audition on PASC210, Weingartner in Basle & London, 1928-1929


--00--


"The Pristine label has one of the most intriguing arrays of historic recordings. Andrew Rose adds to the attraction by regularly striking out in surprising repertoire directions. He also does work for other labels. An example is his recent Warlock set for The Divine Art. These Sibelius discs continue a line established by his accomplished reissue of the Ormandy monos of symphonies 4 and 5 on PASC177.

PASC 204 gives us a good conspectus of Sibelius on 78 beyond the confines of the Sibelius Society shellac volumes. Its coverage is restricted to the smaller-scale works available on 78s at least to the well-heeled UK enthusiast in the 1930s and early 1940s. Kajanus conducts the Royal Philharmonic Society orchestra in 1930 in two movements from Karelia letting us hear his sturdy no-nonsense readings through a bristle of shellac surface. Heward’s Birmingham Rakastava catches all the elusive razory magic hemmed in between The Tempest and the Humoresques. These are surprisingly taut and well judged recordings. Do sample The Road to the Beloved movement: you will be impressed for sure. Heward was a great loss to Sibelians everywhere and the point is further pressed home with a very impressive Elegie from King Christian II. Ormandy’s 1940 Swan gleams with powerhouse brightness which cannot help but impress although I am still recommending Morton Gould’s extraordinary 1960s recording recently reissued by HTT in glowing sound as well as Mravinsky’s Moscow live version. The Beecham 1935 Festivo with the LPO is a fine example of Sibelius’s lighter fancy unleashed – complete with Carmen castanets and a Hispanic Chabrier wink. Kajanus’s four movement suite from Belshazzar’s Feast has its unsettling parallels with Nielsen’s later Aladdin music. In the Oriental Procession one has the sense of being carried forward on a heavy-duty flying carpet. The oppressive stride of the Procession relents for the enchanted slow-tolling Solitude and the unearthly shimmer of Night Music. Such buzzing tension as may have built across the three previous movements is released by the chirrup and chatter of Khadra’s Dance. It is surprising that Beecham did not fasten on this last piece as one of his ‘lollipops’. Kajanus here conducts the LSO in 1932. We next flit across the Atlantic again – this time to Boston and Koussevitsky for The Maidens with Roses from Swanwhite. Koussevitsky is a renowned Sibelian yet for me this version seems ponderous. I remember being similarly disappointed with his way with Sibelius 2 and 5. After the orchestral bon-bons come four chamber pieces. The two movements from Danses Champêtres are sweetly and then elvishly addressed by the slender tones of Telmanyi. The op. 78 Romance bids well into Kreisler territory with a nostalgic backward glance at Sibelius’s ambitions as a solo violinist. Louis Jensen’s bleak Malinconia for cello and piano agains looks to violinistic examples and the Violin Concerto. These last four chamber tracks sound very fine indeed and Werschenskaya’s piano registers astonishingly well given the age of the recording.

Pristine work closer to the cliff-edge of copyright lapse for the mono Ormandy disc. Here they revive a Sibelius Columbia mono LP from the mid-1950s (ML-5249). These readings were not completely unknown to determined CD-based Sibelians; I heard them in a private transfer some years ago. The very fine transfers by Mark Obert-Thorn bring devastatingly home the Philadelphia’s virtuoso excellence in the service of Sibelius’s untamable imagination. They give us a really heart-pulsing En Saga. It is so fast that once I caught myself regretting that the woodwind figures were not allowed to unfold at a less hurried rate. It is sometimes as if Ormandy was looking to the example of that Soviet ‘speed merchant’ Nikolai Golovanov who often dealt in adrenaline and flames. Even so at 11:12 Ormandy and his Fabulous Philadelphian wind principals catch the still heart of the music and then intoxicatingly light the blue touchpaper at 11:46. The string figures swirl and volplane like a Sabrejet of that era and the horns call out with emphatic urgency. As the climax passes the shudder and rictus of the strings at 13:30 is gloriously done. The analogue hush adds to the effect. If you fast-forward to my stereo reference version of En Saga with Horst Stein and an orchestra often denigrated, the Suisse Romande, you will find similar intensity. Stein who must have drilled the OSR to a sharpened point allows a little more oxygen in the bloodstream and slightly more spacious tempo. Van Beinum’s En Saga is well worth hearing too – Hall of Fame stuff – it’s on Eloquence. In similar fiery vein is Furtwängler’s 1940s Berlin version even if he does take a full 5 minutes longer. Stein and his Decca engineers also provide a masterly Pohjola’s Daughter with comparable virtues. Ormandy presses forward but the pacing and tension is just superbly weighed and his predilection for the furies can be felt in the evenly whipped string whirlwinds that provide an ostinato at 6:55 and later. Magical emphasis is given to the harp. In Oceanides the accelerator is depressed too far. Ormandy dispatches it in 8:24 which feels at least a minute too fast. If you like your Oceanides on a jet-ski then this may be for you; not me. It’s as striking as Paavo Järvi’s Nightride on Virgin Classics. Tapiola is taken at a more evolutionary tempo. It is more pensive though it is, as expected, flammable and inflamed for the great storm that howls the pine trees double at 15:03. Again I must point you to Van Beinum and that Eloquence set if you want to hear one of the world’s greatest ever Tapiolas; this is not far behind. Van Beinum shaves 5 seconds off Ormandy’s timing.

We must hope that Pristine will also revive Ormandy’s mono Lemminkainen Legends from another 1950s Columbia.

As for the Alfvén it gets a lunging and plunging sparkling-eyed performance; the best I have ever heard. There’s no hesitation here. It’s played up a storm. I have found this piece queasy and unengaging in the past but this makes it something very special indeed. I am reminded of the transformational way Paavo Rautio had with the Madetoja’s Second Symphony and Karel Sejna had with the Fibich Third Symphony. I hope Alfvén was able to hear this recording and that I am not going to be told by one of the cognoscenti that Alfvén hated it! If he did then I dissent.

The liner-notes drawn largely from Wikipedia are on the back of the insert with a note on the magical and meticulous pitch restoration work Mark Obert-Thorn had to do so that we can hear the Alfvén properly for the first time. I wonder how many expatriate Swedes familiarised themselves with this work from concert performances of the piece by Ormandy."

-- Rob Barnett at Musicweb International on Pristine's recent Sibelius issues.


--00--


"Hi .. I've just been told that the silly old buffer ****** has fallen for an early April Fools spoof by David Hurwitz re those alleged M&A Beecham / Seattle CDs .. He took you to task for not knowing what your competitors were up to .. now read this ! ... 42 encores of Espana indeed ... Tell him to wake up and smell the coffee !
 
 
3. Beecham in Seattle: The Complete Concerts (Music and Arts).
During the period 1941-44, Sir Thomas Beecham established a strong rapport with the Seattle Symphony Orchestra. Private recordings of these legendary concerts have been rumored to exist but were only recently rediscovered, and their provenance remains somewhat mysterious. The original source material is in remarkably poor condition, but Music and Arts, knowing that fans of historical recordings don’t especially care, is issuing them anyway on 37 very full CDs. Fans of Beecham will enjoy comparing numerous versions of some of his proprietary repertoire, including 14 performances of Sibelius’ Tapiola, 23 of Delius’ North Country Sketches, 3 complete cycles of Haydn’s “London” Symphonies, Beecham’s own suite from Strauss’ Ein Heldenleben, and a whopping 42 encores of Chabrier’s España."

-- Mr. A. Regular-Correspondent (reproduced here for the joy of reprinting the spoof!)


--00--


"Hi, I downloaded the first disc and I was amazed with the results. I'm looking forward to the remaining discs."

-- He who provided the Beecham Seattle transfers on the first release


--00--


"...Still in shock, I retreated to my study where my sanity was saved by Pristine Classical. Thanks to the internet, I can still get at music and play it through my computer loudspeakers or through my clever iPod. This is where www.pristineclassical.com came in. The clever folk at Pristine resurrect older recordings that are out of copyright in Europe and make them available as downloads. What they have done is, from time to time, little short of miraculous. I have recently enjoyed, among other things, two CD equivalents of Eugene Ormandy conducting Sibelius (PASC205 and PASC177), Serge Koussevitsky’s 1939 performance of Debussy’s La Mer (PASC018) and the performance of Wagner’s Das Rheingold from the 1953 Bayreuth Festival conducted by Clemens Krauss. Now the Krauss is my favourite Ring of the moment, and I own it in two other incarnations, so I am in a good position to judge the improvements that Andrew Rose has achieved. The sound is more open and focused than ever before and it is a real treat to hear the finest singers of their generation sing their signature roles in a faithful representation of the Bayreuth ‘noise’. The audio spectrum has been cleaned at the top and opened out at the bottom. Hans Hotter sings his best Wotan, slightly more sensitively than for Keilberth in the Testament stereo Ring, and in far fresher voice than for Solti in the 1960s. Astrid Varnay is marvellous as Brunnhilde, and has the benefit of really attentive, flexible conducting. Clemens Krauss’ approach may not be to everyone’s taste, being at the other end of the tempo spectrum to Knappertsbusch, but to my ears the naturalness of what he does serves the composer without drawing attention to itself. This Das Rheingold (PACO039) is available in a variety of options..."

-- Fr Amictus Crotchet
Parish Priest, St Bibulus of Saragossa, East Finchley.

(from a column in "Forward Plus, a free quarterly church newspaper for the traditionalist wing of the Church of England")









 

 

Google
 
Web Pristine Classical

 

 

Pristine Classical - DRM-free historic FLAC and MP3 downloads since 2005