Pristine Classical e-Newsletter - Click here to subscribe
Pristine News: Friday 24th April, 2010


Mengelberg
Willem Mengelberg


In this week's newsletter:

  • New this week - Jaw dropping sound: Mengelberg's 1940 Beethoven & Brahms 1st Symphonies
  • New this week - Karajan in New York Vol 1: Beethoven's 9th with the New York Philharmonic in 1958
    "The New York Philharmonic gave Mr. von Karajan playing that had delicacy and muscularity, tenderness and power..." NY Times, 1958
  • Guest Editorial - Peter Harrison on Faith in High Fidelity - Part 1
  • BBC Radio Special - BBC Radio Four investigates remastering, featuring Pristine Audio
  • PADA - Garry Moore narrates Peter & The Wolf and Carnival of the Animals
  • Reviews - From Audiophile Audition and MusicWeb International
    - "This performance well qualifies as the best Stravinsky you have heard in a long time"
    - "Splendid work all round, and a fitting conclusion to the run of the Flonzaley’s electric discs"





Guest Editorial - Peter Harrison: "Of Hi-Fi And Faith"

Prelude: Originally I had intended to write a short, pungent editorial for Andrew but it increasingly began to look like an irrational, emotional tirade. I threw it away and started again, and here’s the result – long enough to need more than one editorial slot but perhaps the tirade, when it comes, will be better explained.


Part One: The Gaining Of The Faith


I have lost my faith in ‘High Fidelity’.

‘Faith’ is perhaps a curious word to use in this context. Am I equating hi-fi with some form of religion? - Perhaps.

To explain, I need to begin more than fifty years ago.  Somewhere I have with an old photo that shows a serious-looking, blond-headed youth in over-large NHS tortoiseshell spectacles. He holds, slightly awkwardly because he is left-handed, a violin and bow. It is me, aged nine.

This was my real introduction to music: as a violin-player. There weren’t too many concerts in our part of Cornwall: in fact, there were none. I can’t remember if the BBC Third Programme existed back then; if it did our battery-powered radio almost certainly would not have picked it up: it had problems enough with the Home Service. As for recorded music, the only record player that I had access to was a wind-up acoustic machine with a choice of exactly two 78 rpm discs: one was “The Laughing Policeman” and the other was worse.

Five years later, all had changed! We had moved to live north of Manchester and I could go to the Free Trade Hall once or twice a week if I wished, to hear recitals by distinguished musicians and - joy of joys - the Hallé Orchestra, more often than not under Sir John Barbirolli. I could even sit in, a spotty youth trying to pretend he wasn’t there, at some of the rehearsals. And there was Forsyth’s in Deansgate where every variety of musical instrument could be seen (and even played!) and where the staff would happily let you listen on headphones in a little booth to any LP in their stock. A short walk away was Shudehill where second-hand and remaindered LPs could be had for pence, and in grubby shops ex-military and broken electronics could be purchased by friend Smith and myself for tiny sums and which we could cannibalise into audio amplifiers and suchlike.

And thus developed in me (and at last we approach our subject) not only a love of music, especially though not exclusively classical music; but conjointly and inseparably a passion for ‘hi-fi’ - though early on what we were creating certainly wasn’t that!

What we thought of by those two words “hi-fi” was simple and the slogan of Quad Electroacoustics said it all: ‘The Closest Approach to the Original Sound’. As religious folks strive for their place in heaven, so we strove towards achieving our hi-fi Shangri-la. Our faith was founded on two precepts: first, that innovations and improvements in technology would allow sound reproduction that more closely approached the original sound; second, that those improvements could be explained by technical reasons, and quantified.

Measurement. We knew that the ear is not an objective judge of sound quality: that studies by, for example, Peter Walker and Gilbert Briggs (I think it was) had shown that adding up to 1% distortion to a clean sound was perceived by most people as improving it; that increasing the volume by as little as 1dB could have a similar effect. And so on. But laboratory instruments don’t lie – if they say something is so, it is so.  There is a corollary to this, and it’s one that I’ll return to in a later part of this essay: if you hear a difference in sound quality then either you can quantify it by measuring it; or you’re dealing with a phenomenon that can’t be measured (perhaps you simply don’t have the instrument to do so); or you’re imagining things.

Both Smith and I were pretty talentless as musicians; my violin left me on the grounds of cruelty; electronic engineering called as a profession. He went off to University; I followed a year later. By then I knew a fair bit about hi-fi: I could draw the circuit diagram of a push-pull amplifier from memory; knew the facts about pickup tracking errors; knew the technical reasons why Baxandall tone controls sounded so nice; could calculate port sizes for a bass-reflex speaker; and . . .

Being an inquisitive nuisance, I would chat to the BBC engineers as they rigged up outside broadcasts from the FTH, and occasionally I was even allowed to help. One day I was invited to the Manchester BBC studios - I say ‘invited’ but it was more like ‘well, I suppose so, but we shouldn’t, and just keep out of the way’, and so got my first long look at ‘professional’ equipment and my first long listen to professional-quality sound reproduction.

It was astonishing. This was hi-fi, indubitably - indeed it was a sound quality that I’d never imagined could be achieved - as Dr McCoy would say, ‘It’s hi-fi, Jim, but not as we know it’. Was it ‘close to the original sound?  A dozen paces from control room to studio could verify this. It certainly was!

I was completely hooked by my first studio visit.  I wanted in! I used every ruse I knew to get involved with the ‘sharp end’ of the broadcast and recording industry, and for a while it seemed that this would be my career.  Then it all went pear-shaped and I was forced by a series of comic events to find a job so I could feed myself.

In the next part of this essay there’ll be much less of the personal history - we’ll jump forward in time to the mid-‘80s and survey a vastly changed hi-fi world lubricated by snake-oil, and the beginnings of the Attack On The Faith.

Peter Harrison, disk2disc, UK





Further notes - on CDs and volcanoes in Iceland, and newsletters missing in action
A number of people have written enquiring about late CD deliveries - thanks to various personal and medical difficulties in our CD department a backlog of orders developed around Easter time. This backlog was cleared on Monday 12th April for all orders received before 9th April. Orders received on or after 9th April were sent out on Wednesday 14th April, the day before European airspace started to close down as a result of volcanic ash.

We are not sure whether any of the second shipment left France prior to the closure of airspace. However, things should have by now returned more or less to normal. In anticipation of a large general backlog we have opted to hold off on further shipments until today - this afternoon's dispatch covers all orders received between 14th April and today, 23rd April. My apologies for these delays - I would urge CD-buying customers to consider download options if this situation is repeated.

(On that subject, my thanks to Mark Obert-Thorn for his quick-thinking decision to 'deliver' his master files for next week's release digitally rather than by Air Mail!)


It seems that our e-mails have not been passing through our ISP's mail server - after a couple of hours of tearing my hair out I've dicovered that they block anything with a TinyURL address, which is a short-cut I've been using for years for our sample MP3s. If you do miss a newsletter, remember they're all online!


Finally a big thank you to Peter for his guest editorial - proof that he's still very much alive and kicking hard! I very much look forward to the next instalment, and wish him will with his continued recovery from ill health.

Andrew Rose, Pristine Audio













New release today:

BEETHOVEN & BRAHMS First Symphonies
Pristine Audio PASC 221

Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra
conductor Willem Mengelberg
Recorded live in 1940, Amsterdam

Recorded in October 1940 at the Concertgebouw, Amsterdam by AVRO Radio
Transfers from Philips LPs W 09907 L & 6597 009 in the Pristine Audio collection
XR remastering by Andrew Rose at Pristine Audio, April 2010
Cover artwork based on a photograph of Willem Mengelberg at the Concertgebouw

Total duration: 73:28 
©2010 Pristine Audio.


For more download and CD options, see our website


The FLAC downloads:

Ambient Stereo FLAC

16-bit Mono FLAC
24-bit FLAC



The inimitable live magic of Willem Mengelberg

In almost unbelievably good XR-remastered sound quality

 

  • BEETHOVEN Symphony No. 1 in C major, Op. 21 [notes / score]
    Concert of 13th October, 1940 

  • BRAHMS Symphony No. 1 in C minor, Op. 68 [notes / score]
    Concert of 27th October, 1940

    Played by Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra
    conductor Willem Mengelberg

Recorded live at the Concertgebouw, Amsterdam


BEETHOVEN & BRAHMS: 1st Symphonies

Sometimes - just occasionally - we truly astonish ourselves with what XR remastering of vintage recordings produces. This is one of those times. Put bluntly, this is not what recordings from 1940 are supposed to sound like.

A happy combination of AVRO radio's high quality recording system and Pristine's XR remastering process has produced two concert recordings with literally jaw-dropping sound quality.

Mengelberg - a conductor from an earlier tradition than the sound of these live recordings suggest - is as brilliant as his Concertgebouw Orchestra. Now you can immerse yourself in two 70 year old concerts which might almost have been recorded last week!


Download long listening sample: Sample MP3 (Beethoven Symphony - 1st mvt)


Notes on the recordings:

Willem Mengelberg and the Concertgebouw Orchestra were recorded on a number of occasions by AVRO using the Philips-Miller film system, an optical system which produced considerably higher quality recordings than just about all of the other methods then available to recording engineers. The majority of commercial recordings were of course made straight to disc, ready for pressing into 78rpm shellac records, but these radio transcriptions were not intended for release at the time, and thus the engineers were free to utilise this alternate system for recording.

With a frequency range was that much wider than usual, and a dynamic range also greater than that of shellac discs, many of Mengelberg's AVRO recordings have long been available on LP and, later, CD, and the sonic advantages of the Philips system have been immediately clear to listeners for decades.

However, using standard flat replay systems for these film recordings to produce those LPs and CDs has only told perhaps half of the story. In fact the frequency response captured by those Philips-Miller recorders was far in excess of the 50-7000Hz (+/- 2.5dB) generally quoted. Although the system did gently roll off higher and lower frequencies, these essential details are often still intact, buried in the recordings as if awaiting a remastering method capable of extracting them and restoring their original levels.

This is, of course, precisely what Pristine's XR remastering system excels at. There are extended sections in both 1940 concert recordings present here where we've been able to present a true full-frequency, 20-20,000 Hz frequency response, coupled with a dynamic range more befitting of a 1960s or 1970s analogue recording - sound quality which is quite astonishing for its age.

Of course the recording system was by no means perfect, and trying to go "the extra mile" in restoring it to modern standards is fraught with difficulties. Modulation distortion abounds in the original - basically whenever the music gets louder, so does the hiss and noise levels, especially at the higher frequencies which were previously largely inaudible. The majority of the restoration effort has then been involved in trying to ameliorate this problem, though sharper ears may still hear its effect from time to time. There is at times also very slightly higher general background hiss than one might expect of a more recent recording.

Elsewhere the bottom end has seen considerable improvement, with a much fuller and richer sound than originally heard in the flat transfers. The use of multiple references for the remastering of the recordings has ensured that the tonal balance is as natural and realistic as possible, and that the two recordings resulted in an orchestral sound which was consistent for both recordings.

Ultimately we have two concert recordings which rarely divulge their antiquity, drawn from mint pressings of transfers made by the company which designed and built the original recording equipment. One will rarely get closer to hearing a 1940 concert than this.

Andrew Rose

NB. Following our issue of these recordings errors in this original description were noted - the optical system was in fact used in only one of Mengelberg's recordings, with the rest made onto glass acetate discs. Our online notes were subsequently revised to correct this accidental misinformation.

 

 

Available as 320kbps MP3, 16-bit mono & Ambient Stereo FLAC, 24-bit mono FLAC, CD
or listen on demand with Pristine Audio Direct Access
(PADA)







New release today:

BEETHOVEN Symphony No. 9 "Choral"
Pristine Audio PASC 222

New York Philharmonic Orchestra
conducted by Herbert von Karajan

Recorded live in 1958, New York

Concert broadcast from Carnegie Hall, 22nd November, 1958
Originally broadcast by CBS Radio, announcer Jim Fassett
Recording designated "Special Interest" due to limited frequency range indicative of AM broadcast
XR remastering by Andrew Rose at Pristine Audio, April 2010
Cover artwork based on a photograph of Herbert von Karajan

Total duration: 66:35 
©2010 Pristine Audio.

For more download and CD options, see our website


The FLAC downloads:

Ambient Stereo FLAC

16-bit Mono FLAC



Herbert von Karajan conducts the New York Philharmonic!

First of three volumes chronicling his only appearances with the orchestra

 

  • BEETHOVEN Symphony No 9 ‘Choral' in D minor, Op. 125 [notes / score]
    Concert broadcast from Carnegie Hall, 22nd November, 1958

    Played by New York Philharmonic Orchestra
    conductor Herbert von Karajan

    Leontyne Price, 
    Soprano
    Maureen Forrester, 
    Alto
    Leopold Simoneau, 
    Tenor
    Norman Scott, 
    Bass
    Westminster Choir
     
    (director: Warren Martin)

Recorded live at Carnegie Hall, New York City

 

"Herbert von Karajan showed yesterday at Carnegie Hall that he could conduct with tension and virility. In dealing with the first and last symphonies of Beethoven he proved that he could combine an awareness of tradition with a strong feeling of personal involvement.

This was, for the most past, Beethoven brimming with vitality and passion. The New York Philharmonic gave Mr. von Karajan playing that had delicacy and muscularity, tenderness and power. It was a supple, responsive instrument. It cooperated with the conductor at every turn. It enabled him to prove that he was a Beethoven interpreter of character..."

Howard Taubman, New York Times, from Concert Review, 22nd November 1958
Full review available from New York Times archive


BEETHOVEN: Symphony No. 9 "Choral"

Herbert von Karajan's outings with US orchestras are almost as rare as hen's teeth. He conducted the New York Philharmonic in just one short series of concerts in November, 1958 - this first of three volumes brings you a quite marvellous reading of the Beethoven 9th, live from Carnegie Hall. It has never been issued before.

As an account it's a delicious reading - "Beethoven brimming with vitality and compassion" wrote the New York Times. Ironically, given the astonishing sound quality of its partner release this week, the sound quality alas is in some ways more 1940 than 1958, coming as it appears to from a recording of an AM radio broadcast.

Don't let that deter you - it's a seriously good and important recording!


Download long listening sample: Sample MP3 (1st movement)


Notes on the recordings:

"Herbert von Karajan (5 April 1908 – 16 July 1989) was an Austrian orchestra and opera conductor. His obituary in The New York Times described him as "probably the world's best-known conductor and one of the most powerful figures in classical music". Karajan conducted the Berlin Philharmonic orchestra for 35 years. He is the top-selling classical music recording artist of all time, having sold an estimated 200 million records during his career." - Wikipedia

Despite his lengthy and varied career, Karajan was predominantly a Europe-based conductor and rarely conducted American orchestras - in 169 concerts in the USA he conducted only three orchestras: the Los Angeles Philharmonic once (1959), the Metropolitan Opera Orchestra fifteen times (1967-69), and the New York Philharmonic eight times in November, 1958. His only other engagements with an American orchestra were two concerts with the Cleveland Orchestra in Salzburg and Lucerne during August 1967.

The New York Philharmonic concerts were split into two groups of four: The first concerts, of 13-16 November 1958, consisted of three works: Webern's Five Pieces for String Orchestra, Mozart's "Jupiter" Symphony, No. 41, and Richard Strauss's Ein Heldenleben. A week later, between 20th and 23rd November, Karajan played an all-Beethoven programme, beginning with the First Symphony and ending with the Ninth - in the case of the Ninth "Choral" Symphony these constituted four of ten performances the conductor gave of this work in 1958 alone - three with the Berlin and three with the Vienna Philharmonics complete the total.


Transfer notes

Each group of four New York Philharmonic concerts received a radio broadcast - in each case it was the third of the four concerts, held on Saturday evenings, which was broadcast on the CBS radio network. At the present time the only surviving recordings of these concerts appear to have been taken from AM broadcasts. Although the quality, both of the recordings and the transmissions themselves is very good, they are inevitably diminished by the limited bandwidth and dynamic range of this broadcast medium.


As a result there is no recorded signal above about 6kHz, and at times some of the very loudest passages sound somewhat compressed in volume. However, with such obvious interest in these rare recordings, made by such top rank musicians, it was clear that they could not be ignored, and we were delighted to be sent excellent source copies by an American collector. Restoration has revolved around minimising hiss, dealing with very occasional light drop-out, the odd click and crackle, and one short instance of line whistle. Thereafter the XR remastering process has been used in order to ty and extract the very best sound quality possible from this compromised source material. Although the results would be considered fine for a recording of earlier years it's clearly not up to the standards one normally expects of 1958 technology, hence the designation "Special Interest" for this release.

Andrew Rose

 


 

Available as 320kbps MP3, 16-bit mono & Ambient Stereo FLAC, 24-bit mono FLAC, CD
or listen on demand with Pristine Audio Direct Access
(PADA)





Next week on BBC Radio Four (available online), the following documentary, featuring interview material with Andrew Rose at Pristine Audio. This is from the BBC's website:

The Art of Re-mastering

Thursday, 11:30 on BBC Radio 4

Synopsis

Sara Mohr-Pietsch explores digital re-mastering: is it the art of restoring music to its original glory; or just another way of selling us music we already own?

The whole of the Beatles back catalogue has recently been re-released in re-mastered form; a quick search of any record store or online shop will reveal that a large number of recordings have been re-mastered, from very old crackly recordings to very recent releases. But what do the words 'digitally re-mastered' on a cd actually mean?

Sara Mohr-Pietsch visits London's iconic Abbey Road Studios (recently awarded Grade II listed status) to meet some of the engineers who re-master recordings there. She asks them and others from the music industry what re-mastering actually means. She learns that sometimes re-mastering can be as much about what to leave in as what to leave out. And is it an advantage to have the original artist involved in the process?

Sara also considers the consumer's point of view; we've already bought these recordings on vinyl and cd (and possibly cassette as well) so why do we need to buy them again? Can the average listener hear any difference between the original version of (for instance) a pop song from the 1960s and the re-mastered version?

Sara looks at the technology that is used to clean up very old recordings, where the music is often buried almost completely beneath noise and the sonic distortions caused by very primitive recording equipment.

Whatever your view is of the value of re-mastering, what is clear is that the re-mastering engineers Sara meets treat the work they do with great care and reverence - they are often uncovering moments in history.

Broadcast

    1. Thu 29 Apr 2010
      11:30






New MP3 transfers at PADA Exclusives
by Dr. John Duffy
in Ambient Stereo

Garry Moore narrates: 
Peter & The Wolf
Carnival of the Animals
 

Garry Moore
Garry Moore

Prokofiev
Peter and the Wolf

Garry Moore, narrator
Philharmonia Orchestra
cond. Rodzinski 
Rec. c.1957

Saint-Saëns
Carnival of the Animals 

Garry Moore, narrator
Grete & Josef Dichler, piano
Vienna State Opera Orch 
cond. Scherchen 
Rec. c.1957 

Click to reveal notes

Garry Moore (January 31, 1915 – November 28, 1993) was an American entertainer, game show host and comedian best known for his work in television. Born Thomas Garrison Morfit, III,

Moore entered show business as a radio personality in the 1940s and was a television host on several game and variety show programs during the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s. After dropping out of high school, Moore found success as a radio host and then moved on to the television industry. He hosted The Garry Moore Show, and the game shows I've Got a Secret and To Tell the Truth. He became known for his bow ties and his crew cut, though he refrained from both fashions later in his career. After being diagnosed with throat cancer in 1976, Moore retired from the television industry, making a few rare television appearances. He spent the last years of his life in South Carolina and at his summer home in Maine. He died on November 28, 1993.

 

 

This transfer is presented with Ambient Stereo remastering by Dr. John Duffy.

Over 400 PADA Exclusives recordings are available for high-quality streamed listening and free 224kbps MP3 download to all subscribers.

Remastered by 
Dr John Duffy
In Ambient Stereo

 




Download or stream this recording and many others from only One Euro a week!

Hundreds of historic recordings are available for listening and free MP3 download
  to subscribers to PADA Exclusives, our €1/week streamed audio service.


Other subscription offers give you full access to our entire online catalogue




Pick of the reviews


From Audiophile Audition



Pierre Monteux: Early Recordings
STRAVINSKY: Le Sacre du Printemps;
RAVEL: Le petit poucet from Ma Mere l’oye; La Valse;
COPPOLA: Interlude dramatique;
CHABRIER: Fete Polonaise

Orchestre Symphonique de Paris/Pierre Monteux

Pristine Audio PASC219, 62:27 [avail. in different format downloads at www.pristineclassical.com] ****



Pierre Monteux (1875-1964) inscribed a series of 78 rpm performances, of which those assembled here prove the most elusive, since his Berlioz and the several works with violinist Yehudi Menuhin have remained relatively current in the collectors’ catalogue.

The feral Stravinsky Rite of Spring (23-25 January 1929) made in the Salle Pleyel (as are all the recordings) elicits an electrical energy quite startling even by today’s standards. The Jeu de rapt punches and shrieks with elemental fury. The Rondes printanieres conveys a menace whose primal power at first groans with the weight of contained volcanic alchemy: when it does erupt, the orchestral definition screeches--quite a sonic feat--given that editor Mark Obert-Thorn often had to work with dubbings made from French shellac originals. Listen to the marvelous mix between pizzicato strings and tympani in the Jeux des cites rivales, the metrics labyrinthine in their own right. The momentum carries into the Cortege du sage, fiendish and excruciating in its ferocity. A lull, and then the pregnant tympani riff that unleashes the last convulsive wrench to the Danse de la terre, whose savage tremolos threaten to shake our world apart.

Part II opens with a palpable sense of mystical unworthiness, as though we had penetrated deeply into the chthonian. Harmonies that might have belonged to Debussy become stretched and distorted into modal insinuations of dark eroticism. The transition from the Mysterious Circle of Adolescents to the Glorification of the Elected One resonates with fiendish power, quite uncivilized, Monteux’s moving his orchestral masses with quick precision. With the Action rituelle des ancetres we enter the sacred precinct of dance and death, the antique relation of festival and sacrifice. The various layerings of string and brass stretti, given their inexorable rhythmic arch, becomes mesmeric and shattering at once, culminating in the self-immolating Danse sacral: The Elected One. This performance well qualifies as the best Stravinsky you have heard in a long time.

The Ravel, Coppola, and Chabrier inscriptions date from 29, 31 January-3 February 1930. No greater contrast could follow the wicked Le Sacre than Le petit poucet from Mother Goose, all tender innocence and childhood devotion. The clarity of orchestral line and the resonance of the woodwind timbres testify to Monteux’s keen ear for shimmering aural alchemy. The music of Piero Coppola (1888-1971) has not survived in the same way that his repute as a conductor endures. The opening surge of his Interlude domatium (3 February 1930)--with its jazzy horn syncopations--conveys a kind of Hollywood sensibility, a raw energy that bustles with the aura the big city. The secondary theme, rather lyrical, blares forth, its large canvas reminiscent of moments from Walton or Moeran. The frequent explosions of sound are quite huge, a large orchestra making its bold claims. A violin solo emerges from the tumult in concert with horns, soft winds, harp, and strings. The music becomes exquisitely bucolic, a lullaby of Broadway--the “Boul Mich”--if you prefer. Coppola applies his own definition of Stravinsky’s rhythmic energy to the last pages, which achieve a kind of luminous apotheosis.

The Chabrier Fete Polonaise (29 January 1930) enjoys a splashy grandeur that might befit a Ronald Colman or Abel Gance epic. The rhythmic pulse remains quite heavy for a French dance, Massenet rather in frenzied parody. The waltz theme emerges from a gaudy mix, with the thump of the polonaise in counterpoint. Perhaps this is balletic mix that would have highlighted the Capulets’ ball when Romeo gate-crashed for love. Monteux urges a superheated account, buoyantly irreverent, almost tinged with Richard Strauss. The constant, interrupted metrics manage to gain an inexorable acceleration, sailing into a rarified paroxysm of jubilation.

Finally, the Ravel La Valse (31 January 1930), which did not share a general international repute that it deserves. Monteux brings a manic wealth of orchestral detail to the score, a wringing conviction that adds considerable drama to the colors with which the score already luxuriates. Controlled abandon marks every turn, every chromatic nuance. The sense of fin-de-siecle, over-ripe energies ultimately in a state of spasmodic collapse permeates this vivid rendition.

--Gary Lemco





From MusicWeb International


Flonzaley Quartet

Bedrich SMETANA (1824-1884)
String Quartet in E Minor, “From My Life” (1876) [24:47]
rec. 19 - 20 March, 1929 in Victor Studio No. 1, Camden


Ernst von DOHNÁNYI (1877-1960)
String Quartet No. 2 in D Flat Major, Op. 15 (1906)[25:12]
rec. 20 - 21 October, 1927 in Victor Studio No. 1, Camden


SPIRITUALS
Go down, Moses; Swing low, sweet chariot (arr. Alfred Pochon) [4:40]
rec. 11 February, 1926 in the Victor Studios, Camden

Deep River (arr. Alfred Pochon) [3:45]
rec. 4 January, 1927 in Victor Studio No. 3, Camden


Alfred POCHON (1878-1959)
Irish Cradle Song [3:21]
rec. 10 February, 1926 in the Victor Studios, Camden


TRADITIONAL
Irish Reel (arr. Alfred Pochon) [2:30]
rec. 4 January, 1927 in Victor Studio No. 3, Camden

Sally in our alley (Old English Tune) (arr. Alfred Pochon) [3:34]
rec. 3 May, 1929 in Victor Studio No. 1, Camden

Turkey in the straw (arr. Alfred Pochon) [2:36]
rec. 30 April, 1929 in Victor Studio No. 1, Camden


Flonzaley Quartet
(Adolfo Betti, (violin I): Alfred Pochon, (violin II): Nicolas Moldavan, (viola): Iwan d’Archambeau, (cello))
rec. 1926-1929
PRISTINE AUDIO PACM 068 [70:20]



Collectors will know - and transfer engineer Mark Obert-Thorn reiterates the point in his jewel-case notes - that many of the Flonzaley Quartet’s electrical recordings were issued by Biddulph in the 1990s. He has recently transferred the quartet’s Christmas Carol sides for Pristine Audio - which I reviewed

The focal points are the Smetana and Dohnányi quartets, but the lighter side of things should on no account be overlooked. The London’s abridged acoustic recording may be earlier and the Bohemian’s may be more famous, but the Flonzaley’s 1929 recording of the Smetana E minor possesses wonderful and salient qualities of its own. Foremost among them is the light, wristy, subtle approach which, allied to the sparing use of vibrato, adds a Gallic patina to the music making. This is, to be sure, very different to the modernity of the London Quartet, or to the echt-Czech qualities of the Bohemian, but no less exciting. It exudes, in short, French lyricism, artistry of delightful lightness and also fine intonation. The recording was a good one and the Victor ‘Gold’ used to transfer was evidently in fine heart; we can hear the inner voices perfectly and thus appreciate the old adage of a quartet only being as good as its second violin (the Bohemian Quartet’s second violin for example was the composer Josef Suk). The unison playing in the slow movement is sonorous without becoming inflated or over-saturated in the Russian way, and the scherzo has requisite rhythmic brio. The tremolandi and sense of drama in the finale are well conveyed.

The companion work is Dohnányi’s Second Quartet of 1906. This was recorded a little earlier, in October 1927 in the same venue, Victor’s Camden studio No.1. It’s a resonant and attractive three movement work that is a fine vehicle for the Flonzaley. Its lissom freedoms are attractively explored and the marvellously rapid articulation of the central movement attests to the technical adroitness of the foursome. They play the hymnal-leaning melodic lines with great finesse and care over bow weight and tonal matching. Similarly the finale’s counterpoint and return to hymnal seriousness are compellingly presented. It’s no wonder that the upper voices remained so strong; by this point Adolfo Betti and Alfred Pochon had been performing together in the quartet for over twenty years.

The ‘fillers’ are delightful. The spirituals perhaps remind one of violinist Maud Powell’s pioneering transcriptions in this arena. Refinement and elegance are the watchwords, and a certain nobility of utterance too. Pochon’s Irish Cradle Song possesses an elfin artfulness and prefaces the traditional Irish Reel - recorded a year apart. Both this and Sally in our alley were without question London String Quartet territory, the Flonzaley’s friendly rivals who recorded for Columbia. The Victor riposte is highly engaging.

There is some inherent mechanical noise on some tracks but it’s pretty insignificant stuff. Treble frequencies have been retained and room ambience is very much audible. Splendid work all round, and a fitting conclusion to the run of the Flonzaley’s electric discs.

Jonathan Woolf




 




NOTE: This e-mail is going out to our most recently compiled mailing list of recent customers and existing list members. If you do not wish to receive any further e-mails from Pristine Classical please contact me directly by e-mail at this address and I'll remove your address from our list immediately. Alternatively click here to unsubscribe - please ensure you reply from the same e-mail address that this mailing was sent to.


--
Andrew Rose
Pristine Classical
www.pristineclassical.com

 

 

Google
 
Web Pristine Classical

 

 

Pristine Classical - DRM-free historic FLAC and MP3 downloads since 2005